Mazes & Mondays: Forgotten Relics

Forgotten Relics and Cursed Trinkets

Ah, the allure of power whispered from a gilded chalice, the promise of glory sealed in an ancient scabbard, the faint pulse of malevolence lurking beneath the innocent façade of a silver ring. Magical items sit at the heart of any TTRPG adventure, but it is the ones with a twisted edge that truly linger in the minds of players. Heroes crave them, villains hoard them, and Game Masters know that a well-placed cursed relic can turn even the most straightforward quest into a spiral of delightful chaos.

But be warned, dear storyteller! It is no small feat to create items that feel both wondrous and sinister, both a blessing and a burden. Fear not, for the diabolical alchemy behind crafting forgotten relics and cursed trinkets shall soon be revealed…

The Duality of Power

The true appeal of cursed items lies in one simple fact: they tempt the greedy and humble alike. What self-respecting warrior wouldn’t rush to claim the blade that hums with eldritch energy? What mage could resist the allure of a tome that almost begs to be opened? However, these treasures should never be wholly kind or cruel. The best magical items have a dual nature, offering tantalizing benefits paired with devastating drawbacks.

Consider these examples of duality in design:

• The Whispering Blade
  A sword that grants unparalleled combat prowess but slowly erodes the wielder’s memories, leaving them a husk of the hero they once were. Do they keep the blade for the sake of victory, or cast it aside to preserve their humanity?
• The Clockwork Amulet
  This trinket alters time itself, allowing the wearer to slow down or quicken events in their favor. Unfortunately, every use seems to bring them one step closer to an unnerving future that only they can glimpse.

This balance of reward and consequence encourages players to agonize over their decisions, adding depth to both their characters and the campaign.

Backstories That Come Alive

A magical item is only as good as the story that birthed it. A chance roll on a loot table is all very well for ordinary gear, but cursed relics demand something more theatrical, more…juicy. Infuse your trinkets with history, atmosphere, and the faint suggestion of a lingering tragedy.

Here’s how to weave backstories that your players will obsess over long after the game is done:

1. Layer the Mystery
   Don’t give everything away at once. Perhaps the party finds a gemstone that glows faintly when near water. It seems mundane enough until, weeks later, they notice the water begins whispering to the one holding the gem. Build these layers over time for maximum dread and intrigue.
2. Tie It to the World
   Link your items to legends from the world you’re building. For example, the party learns that their prized chalice belonged to a long-dead king known for his insatiable thirst for gold. Naturally, they’ll wonder why it always seems heavier than it should be…
3. Make It Personal
   Connect the item to a party member’s backstory. A cursed ring might bear the same sigil as the wizard’s estranged mentor, or an amulet may carry an engraving that matches the rogue’s long-missing family crest. The more personal the connection, the harder it becomes to simply cast these items aside.

The Integration of Ominous Trinkets

To truly ensure these items take on a life of their own, integrate them seamlessly into the story. Don’t simply hand over a mysterious artifact and expect the players to do the heavy lifting. Guide their descent into obsession with subtle, sinister nudges.

Here’s how to work these treasures into the narrative in ways that enhance storytelling and engagement:

1. Curse Progression
   A cursed item need not fully reveal its nature when first claimed. Begin with subtle clues, like strange dreams or minor inconveniences, and escalate over time. That shimmering crown might initially grant the bard immense charisma, but later… why does it seem impossible to remove? And whose voice is whispering in their ear when no one else is near?
2. Temptation Is Key
   Make the benefits so tempting that players are willing to risk the consequences. Bonus damage, rare abilities, shortcuts past challenges—in the hands of the reckless or ambitious, cursed items become tools of immense utility and narrative tension.
3. NPC Reactions
   Non-player characters can offer hints about the relic’s true nature without giving away the game. An old hermit may recoil at the sight of a cursed necklace or plead with the adventurers to bury the sword they just polished. Their reactions will fuel the players’ curiosity (and paranoia).
4. Catalyst for Chaos
   A cursed relic is never just a tool; it’s a storyline waiting to happen. Play upon your players’ attachment to the item. What happens when an NPC demands they surrender their beloved trinket due to its ties to an ancient evil? Or worse, what if they finally uncover a way to uncurse it, only to learn the process is irreversible and deadly?

The Beauty of Uncertain Salvation

The brilliance of cursed relics is that they blur the lines between salvation and damnation. They force players to reflect on what they are willing to risk for victory, for wealth, for survival. A sword that can kill the campaign’s Big Bad in one hit but curses the wielder to die within days? That’s not just a magical item—that’s a moral dilemma wrapped in glittering steel.

For Dungeon Masters, these sinister wonders also breathe new life into old narratives. Giving villains their own cursed trinkets can add unexpected depth and explain their downfall. A renowned sorcerer who traded their sanity for unparalleled power speaks more to the human condition than a generic mad mage with a glowing staff.

Create. Tempt. Destroy.

Forgotten relics and cursed trinkets offer thrills beyond mere combat stats or loot modifiers. They are wicked little parcels of narrative potential, waiting to blossom into seeds of drama and consequence. Whether they doom your party or spur their greatest victories is immaterial. What matters is the story they leave in their wake, like ghostly handprints on the campaign’s fabric.

Now, go forth and forge treasures of beauty and dread, oh keepers of Mazes and Mondays. But be careful, lest you weave an item so enthralling that even you can’t resist its call. And remember, the most cursed trinket of all… is a glittering gem rolled into the hands of an unsuspecting bard.

Happy haunting, fellow GMs.

Dear crow Crew, please peruse our collection of articles and collect any you may have missed: Blog Index