Worlds and Wednesdays: The Only Reason to Play

A few honest words about why The Worlds of Pulp™ exists, and what a game is really for

I want to talk with you about something personal tonight. It isn’t a new rule, a Pocket World, or a casting sheet of crooks. It’s the reason behind all of those things, and the reason Scaldcrow Games exists at all.

The Worlds of Pulp™ did not come from nowhere. It grew out of frustration, and I mean that kindly. For decades, I sat at gaming tables and ran into the same walls again and again. Character creation took an entire evening before anyone rolled a single die in anger. Rules got in the way of the story at the exact moment the story mattered most. A beloved character would hit a ceiling, a level cap or a campaign’s natural end, and the player would be told, in so many words, that the fun was over. Start again. Roll someone new.

Those were the inadequacies I kept bumping into. They weren’t anyone’s fault. Every designer works with the knowledge, the tools, and the market of their time. Many of those older games were brilliant in ways we still haven’t fully appreciated. But the gaps were real, and I felt them as a player and as a game master.

What surprised me, as the years went on, was how many of those same gaps followed us into modern gaming. We have more creative designers now than ever before. We have beautiful books, clever mechanics, and entire worlds built with real love and imagination. And yet many of those creative attempts have quietly fallen by the wayside. Companies come and go. Lines get discontinued. Games that deserved long lives at the table end up as handsome spines on a shelf.

I am not trying to revive the past. I want to be very clear about that. Nostalgia is a pleasant place to visit, but it’s a poor place to live. What I believe is simpler: the lessons of the past should not be overlooked. The old games taught us what worked and what didn’t. If we ignore those lessons, we simply build the same walls again with fresher paint.

Bought, Collected, and Shelved

Here is the part that weighs on me most.

Over time, I’ve watched a quiet shift in how many of us relate to roleplaying games. Games are bought, invested in, collected, and shelved. They are admired. They are discussed, reviewed, and debated. But too often, they are not played.

I understand the pull. I feel it myself. There’s real joy in holding a new book, flipping through the art, and imagining the campaign you’ll run someday. Collecting is not a sin, and I’d be a hypocrite to say otherwise.

But somewhere along the way, I’ve seen accomplishment get pinned to the wrong thing. Some of us measure our hobby by what we own, or by how faithfully we can rebuild an old game into a new form. Those are genuine skills, and they take real effort. Still, I can’t shake the feeling that it’s a hollow goal if the game never reaches a table. A game that is reconstructed perfectly and never played is a beautiful engine that never leaves the garage.

The truth, as I see it, is this: the only good reason to invest in a game is because you want to play it. There can be no better reason to play a game than to play the game.

There Is No Conflict

People sometimes expect me to take sides in the old arguments. Tabletop versus video games. Old school versus new. Crunchy versus light.

I won’t, because I don’t see a conflict.

If you love tabletop roleplaying games, play tabletop roleplaying games. If you love computer games, play those, and enjoy them for what they are. A video game can do things a table never can, and a table can do things no screen will ever manage. Neither one cancels the other out. I have played them all, and I’m grateful for every one.

The question I care about isn’t which game you play. It’s whether you play.

The Museum in My Basement

I’ll let you in on something. Downstairs in my house, I keep a library of more than 3,000 games. Tabletop games, board games, computer games, boxed sets, and small press booklets that maybe a few hundred people ever saw.

I don’t think of that room as a trophy case. I think of it as a museum of creativity and ingenuity.

I spend real time down there. I pull a game off the shelf and study what it was trying to do. How did this designer handle combat? How did that one get players invested in a world in under ten minutes? Where did this brilliant idea stumble, and why? Some of those games accomplished their goals beautifully. Others missed by a mile, and I often learn even more from those.

Every one of them is a teacher. Every one of them represents a person, or a small group of people, who sat down and tried to make something wonderful. I respect that deeply, whether the result worked or not. When I sit down to design, I carry those lessons with me. The Worlds of Pulp™ is, in many ways, a long letter of thanks to every game on those shelves, along with an honest attempt to fix what kept getting in the way.

Why I Make Games

So let me tell you plainly why I make games.

I make them for exactly one reason. They should be fun.

Not fun for the first session and tedious by the fifth. Not fun until your character reaches some arbitrary limit and gets retired. Fun for as long as you want to keep playing. That’s the heart of The Worlds of Pulp™. Character creation is fast, so you’re playing in minutes instead of hours. The rules stay out of the way of the story. And your characters don’t have to end just because a campaign does. The Pocket Worlds™ let you carry the heroes you love from a haunted Virginia town to a neon-soaked crime city to anywhere else your imagination wants to wander.

If you’ve grown attached to a character, a grizzled detective, a reluctant monster hunter, or a two-fisted adventurer with a bad habit of opening the wrong door, I want you to keep playing them. For a year. For ten years. For as long as they make you smile.

That’s not a marketing line. That’s the whole philosophy. Everything else is just details.

An Invitation

I’ll leave you with a small request. This week, go to your own shelf. Find one game you’ve been meaning to play, any game from any publisher, and put it on the table. Call your friends. Order the pizza. Roll the dice. Play the thing.

And if you’d like to see what fast, story-first pulp gaming feels like, visit Scaldcrow.com to pick up The Worlds of Pulp™ core rules. Become a reader of The Cosmic Skull newsletter, too, so you can follow along with every new Pocket World™ we open.

Games are meant to be played. Let’s go play them.

I’ll see you next Wednesday.

Want more Gamer? Look no further! Check out our other articles in our blog’s ARTICLE INDEX.